Hospital exit survey points to onerous rosters, lengthy commutes, and inflexible work arrangements among reasons for departures of healthcare workers

Cost of living, long commutes, excessive workload, and onerous rosters were all given as reasons for healthcare workers at one busy hospital resigning from their post.

An exit survey from Beaumont in Dublin details a wide variety of causes for staff departures as almost every major hospital faces enormous challenges in retaining employees and attracting new ones.

The study showed that 12% of staff had left Beaumont for an “improved commute” while 11% said they had to give up their job because of the “cost of living” in the Greater Dublin area.

The most significant factor cited in the exit survey was “work life balance” by 13% of departing employees while 12% were moving on because of promotion or a new career development opportunity.

Around one in six of the staff leaving were planning to move abroad, around half of them to take up another healthcare job overseas and the other half for travel reasons.

Problems at work were also cited with 10% blaming “excessive workload”, 9% unhappy with “onerous rosters [or] shifts” and 8% saying there was a “lack of senior support”.

Case for €11 million state purchase of Dowth estate was “compelling” and “once-in-a-generation” chance

A business case for the controversial €11 million purchase of a 550-acre estate in Co Meath for a national park said the argument for buying it was “compelling” and that it was a “once-in-a-generation” opportunity for the Irish state.

A copy of the report said the Dowth Demesne with its large Georgian country house embodied the “most historic and quite literally magical elements of Irish culture” and was unquestionably of global significance.

The business case said the property had come on the market with a guide price of €10 million and urged opening negotiations immediately, seeking approval from the Department of Public Expenditure, and sourcing funding for the land and the cost of managing a national park on the site.

A note from Niall Ó Donnchú, the Director General of the National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS), said: “Minister, this is a site of global importance, unique on this island for its archaeological, built and natural heritage.

“Its attributes as a national park, managed by NPWS, with OPW working in partnership on the built and historic components, are unprecedented.”

Mr Ó Donnchú also said its geographic locations would help boost tourism in the North East of the country, present “cross-border opportunities” and could become a “beacon project to punctuate the decade of centenaries”.

The business case for the project said the new national park would be modest in size and that purchase would ensure no “inappropriate development” could take place on the lands.

It added: “In this era of a twin biodiversity and climate crisis, protecting what we can, as soon as we can, and to the highest standard that we can is the least that can be expected of our generation.”

Fáilte Ireland hit pause button on advertising during Dublin rioting amid fears marketing material could be turned into embarrassing memes

Fáilte Ireland were fearful their marketing campaigns for Dublin could end up being used in social media “memes and gifs” as rioting engulfed the capital city in November.

The tourism agency temporarily pulled all promotion of the city due to the “shocking incidents” that were taking place with shops looted, buses and Luas trams burned, and gardaí assaulted.

In internal emails, staff said their adverts needed to be pulled as they would seem “inappropriate while there was so much devastation happening in the city centre”.

One message said: “In addition, we were really concerned that our messages would add to the negative messages on social media around Dublin, with memes and gifs being created that would create ridicule and more negative content about the city.”

Read the full set of records below:

Finance Minister wanted to at least double take from bank levy as he said banks were enjoying huge profits largely sheltered from tax due to losses from Celtic Tiger crash

Finance Minister Michael McGrath was determined to increase the amount of money taken in from the bank levy as he said every indication was that the banks were going to enjoy “very significant profits”.

In pre-budget discussions, Mr McGrath said he wanted to aim for a take of “considerably higher” than €150 million from the banks as they were doing very well and much of their profit was “sheltered from tax” due to massive losses incurred during the financial crisis.

During the deliberations, the Finance Minister was also warned that any extension of the bank levy outside of the main banks was likely to face legal challenge in the courts.

In a series of submissions for the minister, officials said there were questions to be asked over why the levy should apply to financial institutions that had not been bailed out following the collapse of the Celtic Tiger economy.

The submission said that the levy had been introduced in 2014, repeatedly extended, and had begun to move away from “its original timeframe and effect”.

It said a number of other institutions were becoming liable for the charge due to how it was calculated based on DIRT payments [Deposit Interest Retention Tax].

The submission said: “Given that such institutions have not benefitted from tax-payer funded assistance during the financial crisis, and indeed my not even have been present in this country at that time, it is felt that they may have grounds on which to challenge their being required to pay the levy.

“Entities might also challenge the rationale for the levy if other providers of similar services are not in scope.”

Drone crash, graffiti and vandalism of national monuments reported by Office of Public Works at heritage sites

A drone crashing into a heritage site, a mysterious series of incidents where locks were stolen and replaced at an historic gate and passage tomb, and rogue metal detectorists were among the incidents of vandalism at national monuments over the past year.

The Office of Public Works said there had been more than three dozen incidents reported since September 2022 with multiple graffiti incidents and blocked up windows getting kicked in.

In April, at the Hill of Slane in Co Meath, a drone crashed into the wall of the college building there, which was reported to the OPW by a member of the public though fortunately no serious damage was caused.

There were also a series of bizarre incidents where locks were cut off national monuments and replaced with other locks to which nobody had the key.

This happened at St Laurence’s Gate in Drogheda, Co Louth twice and also at the passage tomb complex in nearby Dowth, Co Meath between February and April.

There were two cases of metal detectorists who had dug up the ground at heritage sites at Kilcrea Friary and Conna Castle, both of them in Co Cork, with OPW staff able to reinstate the disturbed soil.

Two separate incidents were reported at Holycross Abbey in Co Tipperary where a lock and a bolt on a wooden door were removed and thrown away.

Then, a fire with paper was lit on top of “rubble stone” which left the rock blackened although workers were able to clean it back up at a minimal cost.

Three cases of etchings on ancient cairns and megalithic tombs at Carrowkeel, Carrowmore, and Knockarea in Co Sligo were also discovered with all of the incidents reported to gardaí for further investigation.

The records were released in response to a request under the Access to Information on the Environment (AIE) Regulations.

Finance Minister rejected advice of officials who strongly opposed introduction of mortgage interest relief in Budget 2024

Finance Minister Michael McGrath was advised by officials and the Central Bank not to announce any mortgage interest relief measures in this year’s budget.

He was told there was no “evidence base” to support any general measure, that it could worsen housing supply issues, would give rise to deadweight, and have the potential to be extremely costly.

Department of Finance officials said even a targeted relief should be avoided on “the grounds of fairness” and that if it were to be introduced, it could be very complex to implement and operate.

In response to an early pre-budget submission, Mr McGrath said he noted their advice and said it was “undoubtedly a complex issue”.

However, he said that some people were “really struggling and we have a duty to see if we can provide some help” asking if a targeted option for those most affected by interest rate hikes could be examined.

In the budget, a €125 million mortgage relief package was eventually introduced that will save around 150,000 home owners up to €1,250 per year in cases where their repayments had risen sharply.

Right to Know wins case over access to records on possible TV licence collection by Revenue

The Revenue Commissioners have been told to release records they hold on discussions over whether they would be tasked with collecting the TV licence.

Revenue had claimed the records were exempt from release on the basis of Cabinet confidentiality (Section 28 of the FOI Act) and under Section 30.

However, the Information Commissioner has found that only two records actually contained information for use at a government meeting.

It’s an important decision which again goes to the heart of what is and is not exempt under Section 28 of the Act.

It only covers records that were created very specifically for a meeting of government.

However, many public bodies wrongly interpret it much more widely as any records relating in any way to a decision or a meeting of government.

This is not correct and this decision of the Information Commissioner upholds that principle.

Separately, Revenue had tried to rely on Section 30 of the FOI Act saying some of the records could reveal anticipated difficulties in collecting tax.

They said this could lead to widespread evasion and undermine public confidence in their abilities to effectively collect all taxes.

The Information Commissioner (OCEI) was not convinced however, and said Revenue had failed to provide enough detail on how potential for evasion could prejudice its investigations, inquiries, or audits.

The OCEI also said that steps would presumably be taken to ensure any tax collection system would be robust.

You can read the full decision below.

Pre-budget submission from Department of Foreign Affairs predicts more than a million passport applications next year

The Department of Foreign Affairs pleaded for an extra €5 million in funding for the Passport Service saying it was the only way they could provide at least the same levels of service last year.

In a pre-budget submission, the department said they were expecting to issue another 1 million passports this year, not far off last year’s record level of 1.085 million.

They also said they expected to deal with a higher level of sometimes complex foreign birth registration applications with figures rising significantly over recent years.

The submission said: “[We have] over 21,000 applications received so far this year, an increase of almost 22% on the same period last year.”

They said the Passport Service was grappling with “ageing systems” and “increased postage costs” which meant a significant boost in funding would be required just to maintain services at the existing level.

The department also said they were looking for €15 million as part of a plan for a new ‘Ireland House’ that will be based in New York.

It will bring together diplomatic personnel along with overseas staff from agencies like the IDA and Enterprise Ireland under one roof.

The pre-budget submission said: “This development needs to be completed by end 2024, as the lease on the current property expires at that time.”

The department also looked for a €2.5 million funding boost to help open up three new missions next year.

These will be based in Munich in Germany, Milan in Italy, and in Islamabad, the capital of Pakistan, and are part of the ‘Global Ireland’ programme to extend the country’s diplomatic reach.

In their ask for overseas development funding, the department said they were seeking an extra €130 million because of the “unprecedented scale” of the challenges being faced by the world.

These included the climate crisis, “the biggest land war in Europe since World War II” in Ukraine, and an increasing number of humanitarian disasters. The submission predated the conflict in Gaza and Israel.

It said: “At the same time, the rules-based international system – a system that Ireland depends on for our continued prosperity and safety – is under profound pressure.

“The requested increase would be used to meet increasing demands for climate finance, to support Ukraine and the interconnected global food crisis, as well as to meet growing humanitarian demands.”

Department of Finance frustration over new €115 million accounts system that was causing staff stress and delays in reporting

The Department of Finance complained bitterly over a new €115 million system meant to streamline public accounts blaming it for incorrect calculations, slowing down civil servants, staff stress, and simple tasks taking an “inordinate amount of time”.

In correspondence, the department’s secretary general said they had even been hit with penalty interest because of delays in setting up basic data using the new Financial Management Shared Services (FMSS) system.

The Department of Finance was one of a number of stage agencies that were chosen for the initial roll-out of what was supposed to be a new ‘simpler’ system early last year.

However, they soon ran into problems with financial reports that used to be delivered in moments now taking extended periods of time to generate.

An internal paper said: “The impact of the reporting issues means that finance officers cannot quickly do the same searches that they could previously.

“Reports that took literally one second on [the old system] take anywhere from two to three minutes to over ten minutes to run and sometimes the same report has to be rerun if the user does not locate the information required.”

The position paper added that reports which were generated were “very cluttered and difficult to read”.

The department – along with the Department of Public Expenditure – said the new system had caused a “material impact on the labour productivity of staff”.

“Staff across the departments and their offices of government are of the view that the system design is unnecessarily complicated and not intuitive especially if you are processing a new item for payment,” said the document.

Oireachtas members reimbursed travel and accommodation expenses even when off work due to illness

TDs and Senators have been paid travel and accommodation expenses for more than 1,600 days’ worth of sick leave over the past two years.

Under a strange quirk in the expenses system that applies in Leinster House, politicians can be declared present in the Dáil or Seanad even when they are not there.

The system allows TDs and Senators to “reconcile” their attendance based on a sick note from a medical practitioner.

Each day of attendance at Leinster House can yield a daily payment between €75 for TDs who live in Dublin up to €283-a-day for those who live more than 360 kilometres from parliament.

There are thirteen different “bands” in the system with payments rising according to how far the person’s home is from the capital and slightly lower rates applying for Senators and officeholders compared to TDs.

The maximum payment is only available for those who clock in for at least 120 days in every year. A deduction of 1% is made for each day below that target.

According to records released under FOI, 780 days of ill-health were reconciled last year, made up of 491 days for Senators and 289 for Deputies.

In the first eight months of this year, there were 822 days reconciled because of sickness, broken down as 275 for members of the Seanad and 547 for TDs.

An information note from the Oireachtas said: “Ill-health [has to be] certified by a medical practitioner as preventing the Member from performing their duties as a Member.

“In this case the Member must produce a medical certificate for the days not attended with an application to specify the dates for reconciliation in the application.”