CervicalCheck: Submissions from the Supreme Court case involving campaigner Ruth Morrissey and her husband Paul

These are the submissions from the Supreme Court case involving the late Ruth Morrissey and her husband.

In July, Chief Justice Frank Clarke extended his “deepest sympathy” to the family as the judgment was published.

Right to Know is hoping to publish submissions from other important Supreme Court cases in the coming months.

With thanks to the Courts Service for providing the records:

Records on the management of the Covid-19 outbreak at a controversial direct provision centre in Co Kerry

These are 200+ pages of records on how Covid-19 infection was dealt with at the Skellig Star direct provision centre in Cahersiveen.

The records have been provided to Right to Know by the group Solidarity with Skellig Star Hotel Residents.

They detail how one doctor described the accommodation as “totally unsuitable” for residents who were trying to self-isolate.

Dr Anne Sheahan wrote: “I am concerned that this location is totally unsuitable to accommodate these residents for the next fourteen days while they try to self-isolate – no place to exercise or get fresh air and if they need to go out they cannot practice social distancing.

“From a public health perspective, I would urge you to consider seeking alternative accommodation for residents immediately.”

The records are in two separate files below:



A breakdown of tens of millions of euros in spending by three Irish universities: Trinity, Maynooth, and NUI Galway

This is part of an ongoing project by Right to Know to publish details of expenditure by third-level institutions.

Under the Public Service Reform Plan, public bodies are supposed to publish a list of purchase orders worth in excess of €20,000 every year.

Not all do and this project is an attempt to fill in some of those gaps.

Some of these records are available in spreadsheet format. If you want a copy, get in touch.

The order of the records is Trinity, Maynooth, then Galway.

A datadump of 400+ pages of NPHET Committee minutes and records

The volunteer group Bravo Charlie Tango (BCT) has obtained these records from the Department of Health.

They include records relating to all NPHET Committees, except the new Vaccine Strategy Group.

The full list includes the:

– Acute Hospital Preparedness Subgroup of NPHET

– Behavioural Change Subgroup of NPHET

– Guidance and Evidence Synthesis Subgroup of NPHET

– Irish Epidemiological Modelling Advisory Group (IEMAG) – Subgroup of NPHET

– Health Legislation Subgroup of NPHET

– Medicines and Medical Devices Criticality Assessment Subgroups of NPHET

– Pandemic Ethics Advisory Group – Subgroup of NPHET

– Vulnerable People Subgroup of NPHET

– Health Sector Workforce Subgroup of NPHET

– NPHET Subgroup Diagnostic Testing Approaches Subgroup

Bravo Charlie Tango (BCT) is a group of over 1,000 volunteer Irish motorcyclists that deliver emergency medical supplies to healthcare facilities around Ireland to assist frontline medics in fighting COVID-19.

BCT works alongside OSVX, a volunteer community for Covid-19 solutions. You can find out more about their work at the following link.

OPW officials warned Minister there would be “a degree of opposition” to reopening of all gates at the Phoenix Park

On July 6, the OPW issued a press release talking excitedly about Dublin’s green lung and how an experiment to keep the side gates of the Phoenix Park closed would continue.

In that statement, they said: “With this in mind, reducing the volume of ‘through-traffic’ is critical and maintaining safe, quiet, open spaces for pedestrians and cyclists to enjoy is a key priority for us.”

A few days later, they made an about turn and decided to reopen all of the gates, except one that is being restored.

These records bring some clarity to why that decision was made.

A text message exchange between John McMahon, a senior official at the OPW, and the Private Secretary to Minister Patrick O’Donovan spells it out.

“As directed, the gates will reopen from tomorrow morning,” wrote the official. “As advised yesterday, there will be a degree of opposition to this.”

You can read the documents for yourself below:

Three historic buildings at National Botanic Gardens were in danger of collapse according to Office of Public Works surveys

The Office of Public Works was told that three historic structures in the Botanic Gardens were in danger of collapse and that loose glass panels in the buildings were a safety hazard to the public and staff.

The Aquatic House – a complex of three buildings in the Dublin gardens – had “significantly deteriorated” because of weather ingress, timber decay, and rusting ironwork.

An internal report said the dismal condition of the complex was in “direct contravention” of the OPW’s legal responsibilities to safeguard the buildings.

Last month, the OPW announced a €250,000 emergency project to stabilise the Aquatic House and remove all vegetation from the three structures.

They said they hoped eventually to “faithfully restore” the buildings and reopen them to the public subject to the availability of funding.

Air Corps helicopter that lost door mid-flight was at centre of same incident in 2009

The Air Corps helicopter that lost its door after an emergency medical airlift in May had been at the centre of the exact same type of incident eleven years ago.

A preliminary report on the incident confirmed that the AgustaWestland helicopter was the very same chopper that suffered the loss of a different door over Co Kerry in 2009 while transporting then Minister Martin Cullen to an event.

The Air Aircraft Investigation Unit also declined to be involved in the investigation “given the nature of the incident”, according to the
internal report.

It also details how the fourteen-year-old helicopter had originally been on its way to collect a patient for a transfer onward to Tallaght Hospital.

While en route, the National Ambulance Service requested they fly instead to the Phoenix Park for the patient to be moved to the Mater Hospital.

You can read the report in full:

Gardaí release details of convictions for officers following appeal by Right to Know

Twenty two members of An Garda Síochána have been convicted of a crime over the past three and a half years.

The records – released under FOI for the first time by the Internal Affairs Section of the gardaí – detail a range of different convictions for officers.

The convictions cover drink driving, misuse of drugs, sexual crime, and an offence under the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act.

The gardaí said details of disciplinary action taken against the convicted officers would not be released because it was “of a personal nature to the individuals involved”.

They said they needed to confidentially maintain details of its disciplinary proceedings and that this outweighed the public interest in knowing what, if any, sanction had applied to the gardaí involved.

You can see the records for yourself below:

Information Commissioner orders release of records on securing of site where notorious murder took place

The owners of the derelict house where teenager Ana Kriegel was murdered said delays in plans to secure the property were partly down to the “notoriety” of the site.

Internal records show how Fingal County Council repeatedly had to make contact with planning consultants for the owners of Glenwood House about their plans to secure the property and surrounding land.

They also show that plans to develop a nursing home on the site are now highly unlikely with the developers intending to seek planning permission for a different scheme.

The records were obtained from Fingal County Council after an appeal to the Information Commissioner, who decided they should be released in the public interest.

A breakdown of more than €364 million in spending by three universities

These three documents provide detail on expenditure of hundreds of millions of euro by three universities in recent years.

The UCD record is by far the largest and covers a lengthy period and some €319 million in expenditure by the college between November 2016 and March of this year.

The UCC data details €11.37 million in spending including €83,000 in payments to RTÉ, €60,000 to Cork City Football Club, and €50,000 to John Banville Limited.

Finally, records have also been provided by TU Dublin for their three campuses: in the city centre, Blanchardstown, and in Tallaght. Together, they cover €33 million in expenditure.

Right to Know is also seeking this information from other third level institutions and will continue to publish it over the coming weeks and months.

The data is available in excel format so feel free to get in touch if you want a copy sent.